diff --git a/src/dusk/ui/settings.cpp b/src/dusk/ui/settings.cpp
index e9ed1eadbe..ab7ffa5a50 100644
--- a/src/dusk/ui/settings.cpp
+++ b/src/dusk/ui/settings.cpp
@@ -103,6 +103,13 @@ constexpr std::array kMagicArmorModes = {
     "Cosmetic",
 };
 
+constexpr std::array kLetterboxModes = {
+    "Off",
+    "On",
+    "Only During Cutscenes",
+    "Only During Gameplay",
+};
+
 bool try_parse_backend(std::string_view backend, AuroraBackend& outBackend) {
     if (backend == "auto") {
         outBackend = BACKEND_AUTO;
@@ -889,11 +896,37 @@ SettingsWindow::SettingsWindow(bool prelaunch) : mPrelaunch(prelaunch) {
                             "during some cutscenes, particularly on ultra-wide displays. "
                             "Visuals beyond the original intended framing may appear buggy."
             });
-        config_bool_select(leftPane, rightPane, getSettings().game.disableLetterboxing,
-            {
+        leftPane.register_control(
+            leftPane.add_select_button({
                 .key = "Disable Letterboxing",
-                .helpText = "Disable the top and bottom black bars during L-targeting, aiming, "
-                            "cutscenes, dialogue, etc."
+                .getValue =
+                    [] {
+                        return kLetterboxModes[static_cast<u8>(getSettings().game.disableLetterboxing.getValue())];
+                    },
+                .isModified =
+                    [] {
+                        return getSettings().game.disableLetterboxing.getValue() !=
+                               getSettings().game.disableLetterboxing.getDefaultValue();
+                    },
+            }),
+            rightPane, [](Pane& pane) {
+                for (int i = 0; i < static_cast<int>(kLetterboxModes.size()); i++) {
+                    pane.add_button({
+                            .text = kLetterboxModes[i],
+                            .isSelected =
+                                [i] {
+                                    return getSettings().game.disableLetterboxing.getValue() == static_cast<LetterboxMode>(i);
+                                },
+                        })
+                        .on_pressed([i] {
+                            mDoAud_seStartMenu(kSoundItemChange);
+                            getSettings().game.disableLetterboxing.setValue(static_cast<LetterboxMode>(i));
+                            config::save();
+                        });
+                }
+                pane.add_rml(
+                    "<br/>Disable the top and bottom black bars during L-targeting, aiming, "
+                    "cutscenes, dialogue, etc.");
             });
     });