diff --git a/data/scripts/story.lua b/data/scripts/story.lua
index d4a7fc1e..518124c8 100644
--- a/data/scripts/story.lua
+++ b/data/scripts/story.lua
@@ -459,18 +459,19 @@ M.SS_ANNE_CAPTAINS_ROOM = {
   talk = {
     TEXT_SSANNECAPTAINSROOM_CAPTAIN = {
       { "check_flag", "EVENT_GOT_HM01" },                                 -- 1
-      { "jump_if_true", 12 },
+      { "jump_if_true", 0 },
       { "text_opts", captainRubOpts() },
       { "show_text", "_SSAnneCaptainsRoomRubCaptainsBackText" },
-      -- pokeyellow scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:64; pokered scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:66
+      -- pokeyellow scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:64-66; pokered scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:66-68
       { "set_flag", "EVENT_RUBBED_CAPTAINS_BACK" },
+      { "no_npc_face_player", false },
       { "show_text", "_SSAnneCaptainsRoomCaptainIFeelMuchBetterText" },
       -- give-then-print like scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm (GiveItem
       -- fills wStringBuffer; the received text reads it)
       { "give_item", "HM_CUT", 1, false },
       { "show_text", "_SSAnneCaptainsRoomCaptainReceivedHM01Text" },
       { "set_flag", "EVENT_GOT_HM01" },
-      -- scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:32-33
+      -- pokeyellow scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:32-33
       { "no_npc_face_player", false },
       { "jump", "end" },
       { "show_text", "_SSAnneCaptainsRoomCaptainNotSickAnymoreText" },
@@ -478,6 +479,20 @@ M.SS_ANNE_CAPTAINS_ROOM = {
   },
 }
 
+do
+  local rows = M.SS_ANNE_CAPTAINS_ROOM.talk.TEXT_SSANNECAPTAINSROOM_CAPTAIN
+  if not require("src.core.GameVersion").isYellow() then
+    for i, row in ipairs(rows) do
+      if row[1] == "give_item" then
+        -- pokered scripts/SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:34-37
+        table.insert(rows, i, { "no_npc_face_player", true })
+        break
+      end
+    end
+  end
+  rows[2][2] = #rows
+end
+
 -- -------------------------------------------------------------------
 -- Pokémon Tower / Poké Flute (scripts/PokemonTower7F.asm,
 -- MrFujisHouse.asm; the teleport back to his house is a warp)
diff --git a/tests/engine/ss_anne_captain_face_bug2189.lua b/tests/engine/ss_anne_captain_face_bug2189.lua
index 507f0fdc..e57fb3a7 100644
--- a/tests/engine/ss_anne_captain_face_bug2189.lua
+++ b/tests/engine/ss_anne_captain_face_bug2189.lua
@@ -59,23 +59,37 @@ eq(entered("red", { EVENT_RUBBED_CAPTAINS_BACK = true }), nil,
 GameVersion.set(saved)
 
 local rows = room.talk.TEXT_SSANNECAPTAINSROOM_CAPTAIN
-local rubAt, optsAt, clearAt, rubbedAt
+local rubAt, optsAt, clearAt, rubbedAt, giveAt, rearmAt, gotAt, finalClearAt
 for i, row in ipairs(rows) do
   check(row[1] ~= "play_once",
         "no bare play_once row survives -- the jingle rides the box")
   if row[1] == "show_text"
      and row[2] == "_SSAnneCaptainsRoomRubCaptainsBackText" then rubAt = i end
   if row[1] == "text_opts" then optsAt = i end
-  if row[1] == "no_npc_face_player" then clearAt = i end
+  if row[1] == "no_npc_face_player" then
+    if row[2] == true then rearmAt = i
+    elseif clearAt then finalClearAt = i
+    else clearAt = i end
+  end
   if row[1] == "set_flag" and row[2] == "EVENT_RUBBED_CAPTAINS_BACK" then
     rubbedAt = i
   end
+  if row[1] == "set_flag" and row[2] == "EVENT_GOT_HM01" then gotAt = i end
+  if row[1] == "give_item" then giveAt = i end
 end
 check(rubAt, "the rub text is still shown")
 eq(optsAt, rubAt - 1, "a text_opts row arms the rub box")
 check(rubbedAt and rubbedAt > rubAt, "EVENT_RUBBED_CAPTAINS_BACK is set after the rub")
 check(clearAt, "a no_npc_face_player row clears the bit")
 eq(rows[clearAt][2], false, "that row clears rather than sets")
+eq(clearAt, rubbedAt + 1, "the rub tail clears the bit before the gift (SSAnneCaptainsRoom.asm:64-66)")
+check(finalClearAt and gotAt and finalClearAt == gotAt + 1,
+      "the success path clears it again after EVENT_GOT_HM01 (:31-33)")
+if require("src.core.GameVersion").isYellow() then
+  eq(rearmAt, nil, "Yellow never re-arms the bit: a full bag still turns the captain")
+else
+  eq(rearmAt, giveAt - 1, "Red re-arms the bit right before GiveItem so a full bag halts with him back-turned (pokered :34-37)")
+end
 
 local auto = rows[optsAt][2].auto
 eq(auto.wait, false, "the rub box never waits for A (bare text terminator)")