diff --git a/goal_src/jak1/pc/progress-pc.gc b/goal_src/jak1/pc/progress-pc.gc
index 787557b1f3..4d66265a54 100644
--- a/goal_src/jak1/pc/progress-pc.gc
+++ b/goal_src/jak1/pc/progress-pc.gc
@@ -2615,6 +2615,7 @@
                    ((= (-> options (-> obj option-index) name) (text-id fit-to-screen))
                     (set-aspect! *pc-settings* 4 3)
                     (false! (-> *pc-settings* use-vis?))
+                    (set! (-> *setting-control* default aspect-ratio) 'aspect4x3)
                     (set-aspect-ratio 'aspect4x3)
                     (true! (-> *pc-settings* aspect-ratio-auto?)))
                    ((= newx -1.0)
@@ -2627,7 +2628,9 @@
                     (true! (-> *pc-settings* use-vis?))
                     (set! (-> *setting-control* default aspect-ratio) 'aspect16x9)
                     (set-aspect-ratio 'aspect16x9))
-                   (else (set-aspect! *pc-settings* newx newy))))
+                   (else
+                    (set! (-> *setting-control* default aspect-ratio) 'aspect4x3)
+                    (set-aspect! *pc-settings* newx newy))))
                (cpad-clear! 0 x)
                (cpad-clear! 0 circle)
                (sound-play "cursor-options")