{ "issue": 5337, "initial_base_revision": "4e716b06078d725a53234503cbefbb340731e809", "integration_base_revision": "3fca2e0ca6e54ba700c286d9a85a9600dee6a19d", "environment": { "platform": "Linux x86_64", "node": "24.18.0", "npm": "11.16.0", "mcp_sdk": "2.3.1", "ghidra": "12.1.4", "java": "Eclipse Adoptium 21.0.12.1+1-LTS", "configured_java_heap": "768M", "configured_active_processors": 1, "query_cpu_quota_percent": 100, "query_cpu_affinity": [15], "query_hard_memory_bytes": 4294967296, "query_early_stop_bytes": 3221225472, "query_task_limit": 192, "swap_bytes": 0, "os_caches": "warm and unflushed; fresh servers, homes and Java analysis", "initial_startup_and_rpc_deadline_ms": 300000, "integrated_startup_and_rpc_deadline_ms": 600000, "product_default_deadlines_changed": false }, "method": { "task": "Full observed procedure inventory, overview/load image and first internal non-thunk function facts; repeat inventory/pseudocode, export Evidence and close.", "calls": 15, "catalog_discoveries": 1, "fact_comparison_excludes_only": ["evidence_id", "raw_result"], "bytes": "Node JSON.stringify UTF-8 of complete SDK catalog, tool name/argument objects and reply envelopes; initialization, wire framing and model rendering unmeasured.", "actual_model_usage": null, "tokenizer_estimates": null, "memory": "Kernel cgroup family peak including file cache at payload exit; post-GC retained heap unmeasured.", "counter_scope": "Verified payload exit while the observer remains alive; final whole-scope counters after removal unavailable.", "latency_claim": "No whole-task latency, CPU or peak-memory improvement established.", "candidate_control_overhead": "Baseline fact-file parsing/comparison is included on the candidate side; its isolated cost is unmeasured." }, "runtime_tables": { "baseline": { "files": 1841, "sha256_sorted_path_tab_digest_lines": "549bb479ed41e9c55505c169e726552b632f0e5341e63194380b8d0ded344658", "revision": "4e716b06078d725a53234503cbefbb340731e809" }, "candidate": { "files": 1841, "sha256_sorted_path_tab_digest_lines": "0ebceab15311cc5ccdcfb92a0891022fc37736f2e7d01e2c1d22e88920df1ca8", "base_revision": "4e716b06078d725a53234503cbefbb340731e809", "source_diff_sha256": "7c460367e77daf2fad507800f1346dcd9e74553999fb049232b33b27684c8f49" }, "integrated-baseline": { "files": 1847, "sha256_sorted_path_tab_digest_lines": "0d1672378dd3989663f7ef9ead3a91f56283dd06868f4574cae4d062dc83b041", "base_revision": "3fca2e0ca6e54ba700c286d9a85a9600dee6a19d" }, "integrated-candidate": { "files": 1847, "sha256_sorted_path_tab_digest_lines": "d4348d25b4b18e371ac63375accd8f14e72197588934f66b8ab2bb7049ddb7d3", "base_revision": "3fca2e0ca6e54ba700c286d9a85a9600dee6a19d", "source_diff_sha256": "7c460367e77daf2fad507800f1346dcd9e74553999fb049232b33b27684c8f49", "driver_sha256": "b0463f8da110dcbae45769045a690dc5accf74791fa53f5086a60e8383f074de" } }, "driver_versions": { "earlier": "b5bf4b378102de16f871c5f13e7302cbdcecbe0a14cc90b30ab80031920aaa06", "integrated": "b0463f8da110dcbae45769045a690dc5accf74791fa53f5086a60e8383f074de" }, "completed_tasks": [ { "name": "baseline-true-4", "expected_projection": "duplicate", "artifact_sha256": "c79bf44242829108e323378531f4ac839513ca1fba45efd6583643526e1e9fd2", "artifact_bytes": 35664, "procedure_count": 231, "selected_procedure": "0x102000", "facts_sha256": "5b826454c00709fb26777e3b6663aa69ce879f51597c54d6ec3021fc1984eb74", "call_count": 15, "catalog": { "elapsed_ms": 1132.755321, "bytes": 3255374, "sha256": "8a646b95cc5607ee57e5a3c0ef480b77e4cec7e5168498e72f511a8af40daf61" }, "rpc_argument_bytes": 908, "rpc_reply_bytes": 473344, "catalog_arguments_replies_bytes": 3729626, "normalized_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 94357, "raw_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 90839, "bundle_bytes": 177922, "phases": { "open_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 913.6441110000001, "reply_bytes": 499 }, "list_documents": { "elapsed_ms": 27770.679519, "reply_bytes": 6029 }, "list_procedures": { "elapsed_ms": 156.53601400000116, "reply_bytes": 125181 }, "binary_overview": { "elapsed_ms": 101.32018699999753, "reply_bytes": 17387 }, "inspect_native_load_image": { "elapsed_ms": 265.31070799999725, "reply_bytes": 101123 }, "procedure_info": { "elapsed_ms": 80.39036699999997, "reply_bytes": 7643 }, "procedure_pseudo_code": { "elapsed_ms": 81.57453700000042, "reply_bytes": 6549 }, "procedure_assembly": { "elapsed_ms": 53.14257799999905, "reply_bytes": 6715 }, "procedure_callers": { "elapsed_ms": 22.954539999998815, "reply_bytes": 6709 }, "procedure_callees": { "elapsed_ms": 8.837930000001506, "reply_bytes": 6753 }, "analyze_function": { "elapsed_ms": 294.8276279999991, "reply_bytes": 56545 }, "warm-inventory": { "elapsed_ms": 49.338327999998, "reply_bytes": 125181 }, "warm-pseudocode": { "elapsed_ms": 16.670878999997512, "reply_bytes": 6549 }, "export_evidence_bundle": { "elapsed_ms": 51.058947999998054, "reply_bytes": 312 }, "close_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 494.6449689999936, "reply_bytes": 169 } }, "scope_seconds": 34.369, "payload_cpu_seconds": 33.150037, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 993923072, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "zero_limit_events_at_payload_exit": true, "final_whole_scope_counters_verified": false }, { "name": "candidate-true-1", "expected_projection": "compact", "artifact_sha256": "c79bf44242829108e323378531f4ac839513ca1fba45efd6583643526e1e9fd2", "artifact_bytes": 35664, "procedure_count": 231, "selected_procedure": "0x102000", "facts_sha256": "5b826454c00709fb26777e3b6663aa69ce879f51597c54d6ec3021fc1984eb74", "call_count": 15, "catalog": { "elapsed_ms": 1208.093488, "bytes": 3255374, "sha256": "8a646b95cc5607ee57e5a3c0ef480b77e4cec7e5168498e72f511a8af40daf61" }, "rpc_argument_bytes": 909, "rpc_reply_bytes": 326642, "catalog_arguments_replies_bytes": 3582925, "normalized_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 94357, "raw_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 22114, "bundle_bytes": 137135, "phases": { "open_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 941.0834749999995, "reply_bytes": 499 }, "list_documents": { "elapsed_ms": 27897.447016, "reply_bytes": 5981 }, "list_procedures": { "elapsed_ms": 136.00869700000112, "reply_bytes": 65589 }, "binary_overview": { "elapsed_ms": 124.65224699999817, "reply_bytes": 17387 }, "inspect_native_load_image": { "elapsed_ms": 249.8859930000035, "reply_bytes": 101123 }, "procedure_info": { "elapsed_ms": 95.36772800000472, "reply_bytes": 6671 }, "procedure_pseudo_code": { "elapsed_ms": 84.8552570000029, "reply_bytes": 6355 }, "procedure_assembly": { "elapsed_ms": 97.34392800000205, "reply_bytes": 6305 }, "procedure_callers": { "elapsed_ms": 8.018889999999374, "reply_bytes": 6177 }, "procedure_callees": { "elapsed_ms": 6.999988999996276, "reply_bytes": 6199 }, "analyze_function": { "elapsed_ms": 271.9528430000064, "reply_bytes": 31929 }, "warm-inventory": { "elapsed_ms": 30.13376900000003, "reply_bytes": 65589 }, "warm-pseudocode": { "elapsed_ms": 7.71154899999965, "reply_bytes": 6355 }, "export_evidence_bundle": { "elapsed_ms": 71.93626799999765, "reply_bytes": 314 }, "close_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 620.6287440000015, "reply_bytes": 169 } }, "scope_seconds": 34.901, "payload_cpu_seconds": 33.834228, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1025228800, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "zero_limit_events_at_payload_exit": true, "final_whole_scope_counters_verified": false }, { "name": "baseline-jq-1", "expected_projection": "duplicate", "artifact_sha256": "b1c22172dd303f3be49e935aa56aa48a8b7a46e0bc838b4997d3bb451495870f", "artifact_bytes": 2267912, "procedure_count": 2276, "selected_procedure": "0x401000", "facts_sha256": "f7b95167c93f2b9129b5a4332590ef6bbb9d7b646d554ba4c396db1055ef0d24", "call_count": 15, "catalog": { "elapsed_ms": 2761.8931860000002, "bytes": 3255374, "sha256": "8a646b95cc5607ee57e5a3c0ef480b77e4cec7e5168498e72f511a8af40daf61" }, "rpc_argument_bytes": 965, "rpc_reply_bytes": 2372592, "catalog_arguments_replies_bytes": 5628931, "normalized_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 536023, "raw_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 533635, "bundle_bytes": 609212, "phases": { "open_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 1856.9621389999993, "reply_bytes": 617 }, "list_documents": { "elapsed_ms": 290349.418768, "reply_bytes": 6167 }, "list_procedures": { "elapsed_ms": 624.2473109999555, "reply_bytes": 1092959 }, "binary_overview": { "elapsed_ms": 214.38793299999088, "reply_bytes": 15727 }, "inspect_native_load_image": { "elapsed_ms": 432.1906869999948, "reply_bytes": 75633 }, "procedure_info": { "elapsed_ms": 106.62601700000232, "reply_bytes": 7813 }, "procedure_pseudo_code": { "elapsed_ms": 165.65909500000998, "reply_bytes": 6869 }, "procedure_assembly": { "elapsed_ms": 98.534897000005, "reply_bytes": 6855 }, "procedure_callers": { "elapsed_ms": 23.43981900002109, "reply_bytes": 6891 }, "procedure_callees": { "elapsed_ms": 9.403080000018235, "reply_bytes": 7479 }, "analyze_function": { "elapsed_ms": 327.3197410000139, "reply_bytes": 45277 }, "warm-inventory": { "elapsed_ms": 396.67419799999334, "reply_bytes": 1092959 }, "warm-pseudocode": { "elapsed_ms": 6.517379999975674, "reply_bytes": 6869 }, "export_evidence_bundle": { "elapsed_ms": 56.13109899999108, "reply_bytes": 308 }, "close_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 550.6349530000007, "reply_bytes": 169 } }, "scope_seconds": 304.543, "payload_cpu_seconds": 294.743485, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1159921664, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "zero_limit_events_at_payload_exit": true, "final_whole_scope_counters_verified": false }, { "name": "integrated-baseline-jq", "expected_projection": "duplicate", "artifact_sha256": "b1c22172dd303f3be49e935aa56aa48a8b7a46e0bc838b4997d3bb451495870f", "artifact_bytes": 2267912, "procedure_count": 2279, "selected_procedure": "0x401000", "facts_sha256": "87722aab25011f1b047eb2bf8302cdbc5a4256c1b7f17d7bd68404a7d191e070", "call_count": 15, "catalog": { "elapsed_ms": 1411.786849, "bytes": 3263492, "sha256": "c754f774156866d70be754e050335d0e4d3a7a6cbb156746cf1f7b5ffa42b26b" }, "rpc_argument_bytes": 974, "rpc_reply_bytes": 2375466, "catalog_arguments_replies_bytes": 5639932, "normalized_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 536689, "raw_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 534301, "bundle_bytes": 609878, "phases": { "open_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 983.5489280000002, "reply_bytes": 617 }, "list_documents": { "elapsed_ms": 270159.690556, "reply_bytes": 6167 }, "list_procedures": { "elapsed_ms": 717.9032449999941, "reply_bytes": 1094387 }, "binary_overview": { "elapsed_ms": 203.3595150000183, "reply_bytes": 15727 }, "inspect_native_load_image": { "elapsed_ms": 362.37314199999673, "reply_bytes": 75633 }, "procedure_info": { "elapsed_ms": 92.72515800001565, "reply_bytes": 7813 }, "procedure_pseudo_code": { "elapsed_ms": 85.43632900004741, "reply_bytes": 6869 }, "procedure_assembly": { "elapsed_ms": 78.87645799998427, "reply_bytes": 6855 }, "procedure_callers": { "elapsed_ms": 32.66119900002377, "reply_bytes": 6891 }, "procedure_callees": { "elapsed_ms": 8.895469999988563, "reply_bytes": 7479 }, "analyze_function": { "elapsed_ms": 343.2701520000119, "reply_bytes": 45277 }, "warm-inventory": { "elapsed_ms": 338.9290720000281, "reply_bytes": 1094387 }, "warm-pseudocode": { "elapsed_ms": 9.391289999999572, "reply_bytes": 6869 }, "export_evidence_bundle": { "elapsed_ms": 82.86341799999354, "reply_bytes": 326 }, "close_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 679.7842850000015, "reply_bytes": 169 } }, "scope_seconds": 279.699, "payload_cpu_seconds": 277.696079, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1111494656, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "zero_limit_events_at_payload_exit": true, "final_whole_scope_counters_verified": false }, { "name": "integrated-candidate-jq", "expected_projection": "compact", "artifact_sha256": "b1c22172dd303f3be49e935aa56aa48a8b7a46e0bc838b4997d3bb451495870f", "artifact_bytes": 2267912, "procedure_count": 2279, "selected_procedure": "0x401000", "facts_sha256": "87722aab25011f1b047eb2bf8302cdbc5a4256c1b7f17d7bd68404a7d191e070", "call_count": 15, "catalog": { "elapsed_ms": 1213.2912340000003, "bytes": 3263492, "sha256": "c754f774156866d70be754e050335d0e4d3a7a6cbb156746cf1f7b5ffa42b26b" }, "rpc_argument_bytes": 975, "rpc_reply_bytes": 1264884, "catalog_arguments_replies_bytes": 4529351, "normalized_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 536689, "raw_value_bytes_once_per_selected_reply": 16143, "bundle_bytes": 345626, "phases": { "open_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 927.8219500000005, "reply_bytes": 617 }, "list_documents": { "elapsed_ms": 391135.781249, "reply_bytes": 6119 }, "list_procedures": { "elapsed_ms": 646.0353969999705, "reply_bytes": 550261 }, "binary_overview": { "elapsed_ms": 198.11136500001885, "reply_bytes": 15727 }, "inspect_native_load_image": { "elapsed_ms": 456.49483100004727, "reply_bytes": 75633 }, "procedure_info": { "elapsed_ms": 99.12928700004704, "reply_bytes": 6825 }, "procedure_pseudo_code": { "elapsed_ms": 114.82446700002765, "reply_bytes": 6584 }, "procedure_assembly": { "elapsed_ms": 80.73368800000753, "reply_bytes": 6444 }, "procedure_callers": { "elapsed_ms": 10.588890000013635, "reply_bytes": 6337 }, "procedure_callees": { "elapsed_ms": 19.5354899999802, "reply_bytes": 6631 }, "analyze_function": { "elapsed_ms": 352.812751999998, "reply_bytes": 26364 }, "warm-inventory": { "elapsed_ms": 197.59054599999217, "reply_bytes": 550261 }, "warm-pseudocode": { "elapsed_ms": 8.122649999975692, "reply_bytes": 6584 }, "export_evidence_bundle": { "elapsed_ms": 61.80356899998151, "reply_bytes": 328 }, "close_binary": { "elapsed_ms": 614.0456879999838, "reply_bytes": 169 } }, "scope_seconds": 399.097, "payload_cpu_seconds": 352.659548, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1088741376, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "zero_limit_events_at_payload_exit": true, "final_whole_scope_counters_verified": false } ], "incomplete_attempts": [ { "name": "baseline-true-1", "reason": "Harness selected subject.sha256 instead of subject.digest.sha256.", "reported_status": "failed", "payload_exit_code": 1, "scope_seconds": 41.401, "payload_cpu_seconds": 39.027824, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1132675072, "observed_procedures": null, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "resource_events_at_payload_exit": { "memory.events": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "max": 0, "oom": 0, "oom_kill": 0, "oom_group_kill": 0 }, "pids.events": { "max": 0 } }, "is_completed_performance_sample": false }, { "name": "baseline-true-2", "reason": "Harness assumed the composed overview provider was Ghidra rather than rea-workflow.", "reported_status": "failed", "payload_exit_code": 1, "scope_seconds": 37.538, "payload_cpu_seconds": 36.599406, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1001476096, "observed_procedures": 231, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "resource_events_at_payload_exit": { "memory.events": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "max": 0, "oom": 0, "oom_kill": 0, "oom_group_kill": 0 }, "pids.events": { "max": 0 } }, "is_completed_performance_sample": false }, { "name": "baseline-true-3", "reason": "Facts and cleanup completed, but the harness incorrectly read a status property from the boolean finalizer and exited 1.", "reported_status": "passed", "payload_exit_code": 1, "scope_seconds": 35.796, "payload_cpu_seconds": 34.736678, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1001455616, "observed_procedures": 231, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "resource_events_at_payload_exit": { "memory.events": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "max": 0, "oom": 0, "oom_kill": 0, "oom_group_kill": 0 }, "pids.events": { "max": 0 } }, "is_completed_performance_sample": false }, { "name": "candidate-jq-1", "reason": "SDK five-minute first-query deadline expired while awaiting list_documents; cleanup completed.", "reported_status": "failed", "payload_exit_code": 1, "scope_seconds": 316.605, "payload_cpu_seconds": 293.28205, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1065631744, "observed_procedures": null, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "resource_events_at_payload_exit": { "memory.events": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "max": 0, "oom": 0, "oom_kill": 0, "oom_group_kill": 0 }, "pids.events": { "max": 0 } }, "is_completed_performance_sample": false }, { "name": "integrated-baseline-jq-control", "reason": "Unmodified-main repeat differs by three observed procedure rows; strict comparison rejected it before export. Cause unestablished.", "reported_status": "failed", "payload_exit_code": 1, "scope_seconds": 276.557, "payload_cpu_seconds": 274.502165, "payload_family_peak_bytes": 1200726016, "observed_procedures": 2276, "payload_cleanup_verified": true, "resource_events_at_payload_exit": { "memory.events": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "max": 0, "oom": 0, "oom_kill": 0, "oom_group_kill": 0 }, "pids.events": { "max": 0 } }, "is_completed_performance_sample": false } ], "capacity_control": { "baseline_revision": "3fca2e0ca6e54ba700c286d9a85a9600dee6a19d", "records": 30000, "baseline": "regression fails with resource_constraint for list_procedures at the unchanged 10485760-byte stdio budget", "candidate": "all 30000 records delivered exactly; raw_result null", "real_provider": false, "production_boundary": "GhidraProvider -> BinarySession -> public MCP" }, "executed_validation": [ { "check": "npm run check", "base": "4e716b060", "result": "6 tasks and architecture guards passed" }, { "check": "npm run check", "base": "3fca2e0ca", "result": "6 tasks and architecture guards passed; before adding the capacity regression" }, { "check": "Focused Ghidra inventory/function/provider and four MCP files", "base": "4e716b060", "result": "246 assertions passed across 7 files" }, { "check": "Capacity regression alone", "base": "3fca2e0ca", "result": "candidate passes; unchanged production baseline fails with resource_constraint; six other tests filtered out" }, { "check": "Existing real Ghidra large-result helper through a private stdio harness", "result": "passed", "successful_calls": 15, "expected_rejections": 4, "runtime_empty_after_provider_close": true, "scope": "oversized lookup/read/annotation/dossier retention and recovery, complete CLI readback, unchanged source bytes" }, { "check": "node scripts/verify-real-ghidra-address-context.mjs", "result": "passed with real Ghidra/CLI/MCP and verified empty descendant set", "scope": "PIE load identity, file-offset decompilation/roles, address round trips, failure guidance/recovery, unchanged source and complete cleanup", "fixture_sha256": "093f8ba3aef80f3d7c0e8f22557e9a8af29505e286835578282b8e32ff804a02" }, { "check": "Final focused Ghidra source and MCP regression selection", "base": "3fca2e0ca", "result": "247 assertions across 7 files passed" }, { "check": "npm run docs:check", "result": "generated metadata/documentation checks and 5 README conformance assertions passed" } ], "unmodified_main_control": { "same_target_digest_and_analysis_profile": true, "expected_procedures": 2279, "observed_procedures": 2276, "missing_relative_to_first_run": ["0x4f9930", "0x5260b0", "0x529640"], "cause": "unestablished; no engine/default-analysis repair included", "interpretation": "The matched pair is an observation, not a guarantee of cross-session procedure discovery or a latency distribution." }, "limitations": [ "No actual model-token or tokenizer measurement.", "Single completed pairs, not latency distributions.", "Unmodified-main procedure-inventory repeat failed the strict oracle; retained as an incomplete control.", "First three successful query receipts used the earlier driver; archived warm results were rechecked when explicit repeat assertions were added.", "Real Windows/macOS Ghidra, other engine versions and real NativeAOT overlays remain unqualified.", "Initial cached baseline build had an unverified payload-exit cleanup observation; a later systemd inspection found its scope inactive. It is not a query measurement." ], "resource_stopped_validation": [ { "check": "Final focused regression selection, first attempt", "abort": "host_available_memory_early_stop", "peak_family_bytes_sampled": 837332992, "outcome": "guard-stopped without final test results; not counted as passing", "retry_budget": "4 GiB hard/3 GiB early, based on the earlier focused run peak of about 1.3 GiB" } ] }