Exemplar ov_SC01_077 @0x8017ae2c (matched-ov077), 3 members. Per-sibling whole-binary byte-gate (G3/P9) is the
arbiter: jtbl_carve -> make extract -> remap_hseq -> make build, keep iff byte-identical else
revert. Tally: === func_8017AE2C: {'isolate-fail': 2, 'BANKED': 1} ===
Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank's per-sibling revert restores from HEAD — an
uncommitted prior family would be lost. Campaign-end R22 verifies the fleet.
Exemplar ov_SC06_018 @0x80184c74 (matched), 3 members. Per-sibling whole-binary byte-gate (G3/P9) is the
arbiter: jtbl_carve -> make extract -> remap_hseq -> make build, keep iff byte-identical else
revert. Tally: === func_80184C74: {'BANKED': 3} ===
Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank's per-sibling revert restores from HEAD — an
uncommitted prior family would be lost. Campaign-end R22 verifies the fleet.
Exemplar ov_SC06_020 @0x80180b04 (matched), 5 members. Per-sibling whole-binary byte-gate (G3/P9) is the
arbiter: jtbl_carve -> make extract -> remap_hseq -> make build, keep iff byte-identical else
revert. Tally: === func_80180B04: {'gate-fail': 3, 'BANKED': 2} ===
Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank's per-sibling revert restores from HEAD — an
uncommitted prior family would be lost. Campaign-end R22 verifies the fleet.
Exemplar ov_SC02_028 @0x801884d8 (matched), 15 members. Per-sibling whole-binary byte-gate (G3/P9) is the
arbiter: jtbl_carve -> make extract -> remap_hseq -> make build, keep iff byte-identical else
revert. Tally: === func_801884D8: {'BANKED': 15} ===
Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank's per-sibling revert restores from HEAD — an
uncommitted prior family would be lost. Campaign-end R22 verifies the fleet.
Exemplar ov_SC01_077 @0x80178d40 (matched-ov077), 3 members. Per-sibling whole-binary byte-gate (G3/P9) is the
arbiter: jtbl_carve -> make extract -> remap_hseq -> make build, keep iff byte-identical else
revert. Tally: === func_80178D40: {'BANKED': 2, 'isolate-fail': 1} ===
Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank's per-sibling revert restores from HEAD — an
uncommitted prior family would be lost. Campaign-end R22 verifies the fleet.
Exemplar ov_SC02_027 @0x8018A564 (matched), 22 members, 125 ins each. Per-sibling whole-binary
byte-gate (G3/P9) is the arbiter: jtbl_carve -> make extract -> remap_hseq -> make build, keep iff
byte-identical else revert. Tally: {'BANKED': 21, 'isolate-fail': 1}.
Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank's per-sibling revert restores from HEAD — an
uncommitted prior family would be silently destroyed mid-sweep (the tool refuses a dirty tree for
this reason). Campaign-end R22 verifies the fleet.
NOTE on counting: the jtbl carve creates NEW split files, so a git-diff INCLUDE_ASM tally
over-reports (removals visible, re-additions inside untracked files not). True count settles
against the stub oracle at the campaign-end R22.
C, unblocked by B's declaration conform. 23/23/16 banked across ov_SC03_107, ov_MAIN_012,
ov_SC02_037 — the first non-zero result on this population (S46 got 0/142, then 0/129).
R22 clean-fleet: check-all 213 passed / 0 failed of 213. tools-health OK.
dedup-check 1949 validated / 0 failed, C1 coverage 249295 (= 249233 + 62, independent
confirmation of the count). Fleet 93.9% instr / 87.2% distinct / 95.72% fn-count.
THE TOOL REPORTED "BANKED 0 / 129" AND WAS WRONG. gate_stage's ladder hands the same
--verified-out path to harvest_verify on every rung, and each rung opens it for write: stage 0
banked 23 and wrote them, then a later rung that banked nothing truncated the file to 1 byte.
The in-memory list uses += and stayed correct, which is why the JSON verdict listed all 23 names
while the file said nothing. dedup_extend read the file, printed BANKED 0, and took its
`if not banked:` branch — skipping add_members_surgical, so the registry was missing 62
memberships for functions already spliced in and byte-verified.
- Registry repaired by deriving the banked set from git diff (+DEFINE_func_*), not from the
broken file. Post-check: 0 missing.
- ensure_include_revert did NOT fire (added_include False, include already present) — the
P29-S19 defect that once stripped a load-bearing include from 135 binaries stayed closed.
- gate_stage now writes verified_out once at the end from the accumulated truth.
Caught only because bank truth is derived from source (§55b), never from the gate report.
Residue (67) is consistent with the symbols B deliberately left: memcpy 17, ApplyMatrixSV 12,
gte_SetRotMatrix 4, plus 21 CC1-FAIL and 3 DIFF. Not separated: how much of the 62 is B's
conform vs the ladder's own recovery rungs.
- BANKED: 11 functions at 400-952 ins from the cascade (func_8017D898 952, func_8017CE58 733,
func_801902EC 673, func_8018C2D8 673, func_8018A8D4, func_8017C6F4, func_800CBB38,
func_800CF3A4, +3). check-all 213/213 from a clean tree. 6 near = jr/switch (§53 separate
banking step), 1 failed. The cascade agents wrote 6 new cookbook sections incl. §158.
⚠️ tools-health UNVERIFIED at commit (stale cookbook index fixed, confirming re-run
interrupted) — run it first next session. check-all is the byte oracle and it is green.
- WASTE PREVENTION (Drew: "prevent this from ever happening again, however you need to"):
* tools/validate_targets.py (NEW) — names 5 defect classes (NO-ASM / MID-BODY /
OUT-OF-RANGE / ALREADY-DONE / NO-BOUNDARY), exits non-zero.
* WIRED INTO wave_snapshot so it fails closed — every wave passes through there for its .s
files, so no path from target list to spawned agents bypasses validation. Negative-control:
a 3-target bad list is refused with the exact mid-body offset (+72 bytes of 100).
* The cascade `done()` predicate now short-circuits on SKIPPED as well as MATCH. It tested
only MATCH, so a non-existent target fell Sonnet -> Opus -> Fable and three agents each
proved the same phantom absent: ~29 invalid targets x 3 tiers = 87 of 119 agents, ~9.7M
tokens. A tier that cannot act must END the pipeline, not escalate emptiness.
* docs/accelerators.md A9, including that wave_snapshot's own R32 assertion REFUSED that list
(24 of 57 found) and was routed around — the one instrument warning that was right and ignored.
- B RE-SCOPED (S46-10) and deliberately NOT done: the extend blocker is INTRA-HEADER, not
target-side. engine_core.h declares memcpy FOUR incompatible ways across its DEFINE_ macros;
two in one TU collide. NOT a safe cleanup — the in-tree note at ov_MAIN_012.c:14333 records
that `extern memcpy` disables gcc's builtin and turns an inlined block-move into a CALL, so the
declaration CHANGES CODEGEN. Probe one macro in one binary and byte-gate before any sweep.
- C (dedup_extend over the 129) stays blocked on B. Full context for both in the checkpoint.
Drew: "make it more multi-threaded... I still see my cpu idle for far too long."
Measured, fixed, and regression-tested against the S46-3 bank as a KNOWN ANSWER.
- THE MEASUREMENT: 31s saturated (33 makes/48 cc1/load 27) then ~25s with ONE build alive
while 31 cores idled, repeating. Causes: ex.map starts in list order so the giants land
last, and apply/restore is single-threaded.
- gate_all -> gate_failures: return EVERY failure the sweep already computed (~138 rounds -> 1).
- Longest-first gate scheduling; results re-sorted into `changed` order so the verdict stays
bit-identical to the serial loop's.
- PER-OVERLAY INDEPENDENT SEARCH, IN PROCESSES. My first cut used threads and the box refuted
it: 0-4 builds alive at load 3, because the work is regex over 15k-line files and 138
"parallel" searches all queued on the GIL. Same logic in a ProcessPoolExecutor: 14-29 builds,
load 34.75, search phase ~100s. Safe because the shared header is written ONCE by the parent
and each overlay owns its own .c files + build/<bin>/. Seeded with one in-process search
first — a pool submitted at once gives every worker an empty suspect list and makes all 138
pay a full bisection. place_in_overlay extracted to module level so the worker and the
in-process apply cannot drift (R33); compiles_standalone's fixed t.c is per-call now.
- THE REGRESSION (the point, not the stopwatch): revert src/+config to pre-bank, re-run the
identical command -> 29 functions (same), 141 overlays byte-identical, 682s vs ~1440s, and
285 exclusions vs ~350 => +62 MORE member instances (249,161). The old prefix-based
necessity probe was OVER-EXCLUDING (charging 4 fns to 9 overlays that did not all need
them); the per-overlay shrink minimises per overlay. The faster path is also more correct —
a timing comparison would never have shown it. R22 213/213 + tools-health green.
- STILL SERIAL, now the actual wall-clock (neither is a build): ~3min setup before the first
gate (registered_addrs() yaml-parsing a 1949-group/249k-instance registry + 213 sig loads)
and ~2.5min of sequential reconcile_caller_extern after the search.
- Captured as defaults: docs/accelerators.md A8 + memory fleet-tool-parallelism-defaults.
cookbook index regenerated (my §155c append left it stale — the gate caught it, exit 1).
The S45p9 blocker is closed, and the recovery loop that kept it from finishing is rewritten.
- BANKED: dedup_propagate --auto-from ov_SC02_037 --recover -> 29 functions propagated,
141 overlays byte-identical, dedup 1920 -> 1949 groups, member instances 246,284 ->
249,099 (+2,815). make clean && extract-all && check-all -> 213 passed / 0 failed (R22).
- WHY IT FINISHED THIS TIME: gate_all -> gate_failures returns EVERY failure from the sweep
that already computed them, and the recovery loop resolves them all per round. Converged in
3 rounds; the old one-overlay-per-sweep design needed ~138. That reframes the S45 run — it
was not nearly done when it died, it had barely started.
- Batching did NOT cost capability: per-overlay necessity probes excluded four of the nine
culprits from only the 9 overlays that needed it (not all 138), and ov_SC07_006 was
RECOVERED by the Part-B caller-extern reconcile instead of excluded.
- Plan phase parallelised: 5 min -> 26 s, plan + skip classification byte-identical. Its
compiles_standalone temp file is per-call now — the fixed `t.c` was the same fake-isolation
class as match_one's shared --work dir (P28 T5), latent until something ran it in parallel.
- docs/accelerators.md (NEW, Drew 2026-08-07): the reusable-workflow ledger — what we learned
late that a future decomp should know on day one, each entry with when we found it, when it
WAS findable, what it cost, and the honest prerequisite where one exists.
ROOT CAUSE of the 141/213 breakage earlier this session (correctly derived this time;
my first attribution to F1 was WRONG -- no arity journal ever touched func_80146A6C and
the arity undo reported success):
dedup_propagate --recover's Part B reconciles a conflicting caller extern and
DELIBERATELY leaves the edit on disk when it buys the byte-match ("keep the reconcile
on disk"). Correct while the fn survives -- but a fn can still be dropped by a LATER
iteration against a different overlay, and when the plan finally emptied, the
"all candidates dropped" sys.exit fired with NO restore. Reconciles kept for
ov_SC07_001..009 were orphaned: no-proto'd caller externs for functions that were
never propagated -> ov_SC07_010 "passing arg 2 of func_80146A6C makes pointer from
integer" -> 141 of 213 binaries failed check-all.
The byte-gate never mis-banked (it fails closed). The real cost was VERDICT VOIDING:
every subsequent gate reported "near" against the broken tree, so two whole batches
(4/4 and 20/20) were mis-read as draft failures when they measured the tree (R35).
FIX: a reconcile LEDGER. Every kept reconcile is recorded against its fn, undone the
moment that fn leaves the plan, and ALL outstanding reconciles are restored before the
failure exit -- so a failed propagation leaves the tree exactly as it found it.
HONESTY: the fix is IMPLEMENTED AND REVIEWED BUT NOT YET PROVEN. The negative control
aimed at the exact failing propagation SUCCEEDED instead (different tree state), so the
guarded path never executed. A targeted test of the ledger is still owed.
Also lands the propagation that control performed: func_8015C030 x7 overlays
(func_80168B70 excluded from 4 SC07 overlays, survived elsewhere). check-all 213/213.
- the gate DECODED from matched C (func_8012832C case 0x300E -> func_80128998 -> streaming
API with &cdFileLocTable[144]) -> scene arithmetic named the 1ST-BOSS arena -> ONE targeted
load captured it at 0x801E4C60
- RETRO-VERIFIED: Phase-3's dumps/ram_castle.bin (2026-06-14) holds it at the SAME address,
same 6,764-B exact prefix — R10 two independent datapoints two months apart;
bossHp_SteamKnight (0x801E4398) lives inside this module's image
- onboarded md_SC02_009 (id 0x3E, TLO 0x4): BYTE-IDENTICAL first build; fleet 213;
R22 213/213; tools-health OK; audit-disc UNCLAIMED 6 -> 5, residue 0
- the last 5 (MAIN/7, MAIN/9, SC03/53/54/56) reclassified emulator->STATIC-RE targets with
decoded leads (memory-map §S45 p3); loc-id map appended to docs/debug-menu-list.txt
- negatives banked: pause menu, memory-box prompt, new-game intro, high/low game, Minku
spawn (slot-A actor 0x15 = md_MAIN_015 candidate naming)
- THE TOUR (Drew driving the retail debug menu; mode-7 hammer over the Redux web API):
all 28 script modules captured live at four byte-verified per-chapter slots
(SC03/73-79 @0x801EF468 ch2-period, SC03/132-138 @0x801E25E8 ch3, SC04/24-30
@0x801E7B28, SC05/23-29 @0x801ED988); the routing law: debug-menu AREA selects the
chapter, each CITY interior streams its own module (member k <-> interior k).
md_MAIN_011/DISELECT byte-proven 24,236/24,240 in RAM; slots A/B/boot R34-verified live.
- MAIN/3 DISCOVERED: the main-menu module (id 0x39, 121,884 B), mis-bucketed as data by
BOTH audit oracles; live byte-proven @0x800CEDF8 (42,632-B exact prefix); onboarded.
- 29 onboardings BYTE-IDENTICAL on first build -> fleet 212; R22 212/212 after three
md_MAIN_003 catches: the A4 DsMix leak; an extract-order-sensitive splat boundary
(bytes: a 1-word data sentinel in .text + fn at +4 -> pinned in symbols file);
corpus.stubs now treats D_*/jtbl_* INCLUDE_ASM as blob includes (mirrors progress.py)
- module-id census (offline, disc-wide): 77 id-law code payloads, 0 further misses;
SC03/55 = confirmed DATA. audit-disc: UNCLAIMED 34 -> 6, residue 0 — the 6 carry
byte-checked negative evidence; next tier = the CD-read tracer
- docs: memory-map §S45 (slots + routing + debug-menu ops), disc-completeness S45
addendum, decision-log R31 entry, docs/debug-menu-list.txt (Drew's transcription)
- .run/s45 evidence allowlisted (tour logs/scripts/rosters); 104 ram dumps LOCAL-ONLY
- new baseline: 93.8% instr / 95.68% fn / 87.2% distinct over 212
- slot A 29/29 (md_MAIN_013..041 @ 0x800CAE08), slot B 6/6 (md_MAIN_042..047 @ 0x800CCB1C),
boot trio 3/3 (md_MAIN_001 [=MAIN/0 twin], md_MAIN_008, md_MAIN_011 @ 0x800CEDF8) — every one
BYTE-IDENTICAL on its FIRST build (byte-corroborating the §S44 loader table for slots A/B/boot)
- TLO roster derived from the §154 id-word law (.run/s45/derive_tlo.py): 0x4 default;
011=0x7C, 025=0xC, 034=0x80, 039=0xC (first-prologue scan)
- new_binary.sh: module hdr carve is now a dot-typed .rodata PAIRED with the c segment —
a header can hold a function's jump table (md_MAIN_034), and standalone rodata emits
.L locals that don't cross objects; bin links in the data block (both refuted by bytes)
- A4 law: symbols.resident.txt dropped from the boot trio's stacks (windows inside the
resident region; DsMix @0x800D1BD8 had minted a phantom fn boundary in md_MAIN_011) —
re-extracted clean, all three byte-identical, phantom gone
- tools/dedup_extend.py over the clean tree (the prior run correctly REFUSED my uncommitted tree,
H4 — that refusal was the tail I misread as a result; and my earlier '0 stubs left' was a
single-file grep -c display artifact, caught before being reported).
- BANKED 4,836 / 5,016 planned (1,612 DEFINE_func per binary; 180 skipped incl. 8/binary
verbose-form). Each splice byte-gated; all three binaries remain BYTE-IDENTICAL (SHA re-checked
per binary post-run). engine_core.h include added -> audit-binaries green again (R36).
- Remaining stubs: ov_MAIN_012 712 · ov_SC02_037 822 · ov_SC03_107 802 = the h_norm-only tier +
the ~802 novel functions (the new frontier).
- Three uncompressed (PAC type-1) overlays at the standard 0x80128158 slot, onboarded via the new
tools/new_binary.sh, each byte-identical at 100% INCLUDE_ASM on the FIRST build:
ov_MAIN_012 d6b3e8b9 (383,783 B, 2,324 fns)
ov_SC02_037 b0c5394a (661,903 B, 2,434 fns)
ov_SC03_107 87d02b57 (474,087 B, 2,414 fns)
This also BYTE-PROVES the statically derived base (the §S44 loader table + the 500:1 h_exact
vote): a wrong vram could not have produced byte-identical images once symbols resolve.
- Fleet: 140 -> 143 binaries. audit-binaries currently FAILS on all three by design (no
engine_core.h include yet — the SC07-blindness check working as built); dedup_extend is the fix
and the next commit.
- Registered by the script: overlays.mk blocks, check.sha, symbols seeds, the 3 BINARIES dicts.
family map regenerated (3,577 target families / 279 with a matched sib — the new binaries'
members now visible).
- func_8018D98C (ov_SC06_033, 710 ins): MATCH, gated, carved into its own split
(src/ov_SC06_033/ov_SC06_033_jr_8018D98C.c); image matches its locked SHA; stub gone.
NOT a family — `find asm -name func_8018D98C.s` returns exactly one file, so this banks 1x710.
The prompt's "renderer sibling" premise was wrong: it is a 12-state entity state machine over
jtbl_801CF234; func_8017C6F4's C shares nothing with it. Structurally exact on the first draft.
- §153 THE ADDRESS-REMATERIALISATION LAUNDER (third zero-emission asm lever, after §148-C's allocno
numerator and §151's blocked scheduler tick): an `&SYM` used as an argument >=2x in ONE cse basic
block gets its pseudos unified (4 refs), so local-alloc.c:1080's remat path (needs reg_n_refs==2)
never fires and global.c:388 hands it a CALLEE-SAVED register, cascading a rename. 14 probes prove
no respelling reaches it (do/while splits cse1; cse2 puts it back). Cure, zero bytes, one per site
in its own block: `{ s32 _m = (s32)&SYM; __asm__ __volatile__("" : "=r"(_m) : "0"(_m)); f(x,_m,y); }`
— the volatile asm is never entered in cse's table AND sets _m, emptying the equivalence class.
Placement is load-bearing (#APP is a scheduling barrier); with two address args, launder BOTH.
- INTEGRATION CAUTION: the agent's TU-CONFORMED variant gated DIFF while the PLAIN one banked.
rtu_match MATCHing does not promise a decl-rewritten variant survives the real build — gate the
plain variant first.
- R22 clean-fleet still owed (one agent remains on asm/); this and the 12 family banks are
incremental-gated (§130) until it runs.
⚠️ R22 CLEAN-FLEET OWED (two agents still reading asm/, so `make clean` is unsafe). Each of the 12
was gated whole-binary AND independently re-checked against its own config/check.<bin>.sha (12/12),
stubs confirmed replaced — but incremental (§130). Treat as UNCONFIRMED until the clean run.
- THREE isolated cheap-Opus agents, briefed with §150/§151 + the mandatory all-drafts scan,
CONVERGED INDEPENDENTLY: func_8017C6F4's 947-ins body exists in 12 OVERLAYS under 5 DIFFERENT
NAMES at 6 DIFFERENT ADDRESSES, each differing by exactly TWO per-overlay symbols (screen-rect
helper + 64x64 cell table). Gated 12/12, 0 failed. 11,364 ins from this morning's single crack.
- WHY IT HID ~30 PHASES (cookbook §152): name-keyed grouping scattered it across 5 names,
address-keyed across 6 addresses (and the address collides with an unrelated 15-ins body in 3
other overlays), and h_seq-keyed scattered it too — which is why the Phase-26 sweeps missed it.
THE KEY IS BYTE SIZE: `grep -rl 'nonmatching .*, 0xECC' asm/*/nonmatchings/*/` returns exactly
the 12, reads the asm (cannot go stale like family_hseq.json), no false positives. Refines the
Phase-26 "h_seq is spent" finding: h_seq is worth exactly ONE size-keyed sweep behind each FRESH
core crack — here it paid 11:1.
- TWO CAUTIONS THAT TRAVEL WITH IT: (1) a MASKED tool cannot validate a remap — match_one and
rtu_match both mask jal/%hi/%lo, exactly the fields a remap edits, so a wrong symbol map still
reports MATCH; gate remaps by the whole-binary SHA only. (2) a stale residual is NOT evidence two
functions differ — I briefed "func_8017C59C scores 340, different body"; refuted in one command
(that 340 came from a pre-§150-fix draft, which scores nonzero against its own target too).
- OPEN TOOL DEFECT (R32): family_remap's unit backscan halts at the first #define, so it carried
16/16 gte macros and 0/10 typedefs, silently — the §146 gap from the other side.
- MY ERROR, RETRACTED IN THE LOG (S43-9): I reported the 263x5 cluster as "5 byte-identical, 1,315
ins". FALSE — the drafts had been reverted, so I measured the INCLUDE_ASM STUB BASELINE, which is
byte-identical by construction. R34's trap, self-inflicted by hand-building instead of using
harvest_verify. Nothing was banked there; the cluster is UNRESOLVED. ("41 behemoth drafts" was
likewise a file count — 79 files, 20 distinct functions.)
⚠️ R22 CLEAN-FLEET VERIFY IS OWED, NOT DONE. All four gates below were INCREMENTAL builds
(§130: an incremental build can report BYTE-IDENTICAL for a change a clean build cannot link).
Committed now only to protect the work — a second Fable5 agent is reading asm/, so `make clean`
would destroy its inputs mid-run. The clean-fleet run follows the moment that agent finishes;
treat these four banks as UNCONFIRMED until then.
- THE CRACK (Drew approved the Fable5 escalation, R27): byte-exact, PIN-FREE, 947 ins. My §147-E
"qty_compare tie, unreachable from source" diagnosis was WRONG. The residual was VARIABLE
IDENTITY: (1) the X-pass and Y-pass min/max intermediates are DIFFERENT variables (8, not 4
reused); (2) mnc/mxc do not exist — the cell clamps reuse the prim-loop mn/mx (X) and mny/my (Y).
Ablations: split-only 63, reuse-only 624, conjunction MATCH. That is also why S42's "separate
X vs Y variables" probe was filed as a failure (it was half the fix), and why every allocator
lever was inert — pins, §148-C sliders, declaration order and 14 permuter restarts cannot reach
a draft with the wrong NUMBER OF PSEUDOS.
- VERIFIED INDEPENDENTLY BEFORE BELIEVING IT (R14): I re-ran match_one -> MATCH (947 ins), then
the whole-binary gate per binary.
- BANKED ×4 (every 948-ins sibling of this body), each byte-identical:
ov_SC03_126 c48a8bb8 · ov_SC03_003 898bf52a · ov_SC04_021 33614234 · ov_SC05_019 3f5b4f13.
family_remap produced all three siblings cleanly.
- §146 SEEN AGAIN: all three siblings first failed with `PLUMBING: parse error before 'MTX_C6F4'`
— _carry_macros carries #defines but NOT typedefs; prepending the 9 typedef lines fixed all
three. That label is legible ONLY because of this session's classifier fix; before it, it read
"CC1-FAIL: make: *** Error N" and cost a manual splice-and-rebuild each.
- cookbook §150 (decode register ownership from the MATCHING diff regions before touching the
allocator; per-instance register asymmetry ⇒ per-instance variables; the deleted-self-move tell
and the global.c:719-vs-:729 death-before-store exemption behind it). §147-E corrected: it named
the wrong allocator — these are global.c allocnos, not local qty_compare quantities.
Answering "did we do S4?" honestly: NO, not properly. The earlier pass re-gated only the NEWEST
stored draft per draft-exemplar head (8 banked of 35). S6 then proved that is sampling, not scanning
-- its giant's match was the 9th of 31 drafts, and my first pass had reported "closeness 40".
Redone with EVERY stored draft run through match_one, over the 39 draft-exemplar heads + Drew's
named large-function list (38 targets, 33 with drafts on disk):
14 of 33 targets MATCH from a stored draft (some had 51-57 drafts each)
-> 6 banked first pass, +1 after recover_giant = 7 banked
-> including func_8018057C (897 ins), which was on the "needs an agent" list
The 14 came overwhelmingly from ov_SC01_077 -- exactly the heads where only the newest draft had
been tried. The winning drafts sit in .run/_a10_sample-cn-cast-rc/, .run/drafts-wave-cn-cast/,
.run/drafts-wave-cn/, .run/ab-exp/opus-cn/, .run/backlog_drafts/ -- i.e. spread across many
historical pipelines, which is precisely why "newest" is the wrong selector.
7 still open after recovery (5 near, 2 failed) -- integration classes, drafts kept in .run/s41/rec/.
VERIFIED: make clean && make extract-all && make check-all -> 140 passed, 0 failed of 140.
Fleet 12483035 -> 12484373 instr; distinct +1,338 / +7 uniq; fn-count +7. instr-weighted 94.9%.
audit-digest OK. 0 NON_MATCHING (G4).
STILL OPEN from S4: the 263x5 cluster (0x80182fd4 exemplar) sweeps 0/5 with `parse error before
'unsigned'` in the spliced draft -- NOT the missing-type class, undiagnosed, do not assume codegen.
And the 2 resident stubs with gate-rejected match_one-MATCH drafts remain untouched.
THE RULE (cookbook §146, now paid for twice): SCAN every stored draft, never sample. A head with 57
drafts has 57 chances, and the pipelines that produced them differ in ways that matter.
Measured the h_exact free pool from the bytes rather than trusting the frontier report's
numbers (R14 — its whale claim was 3/4 wrong: it said the whale was open in all four SC07
overlays; three were already banked and I closed the fourth earlier this session).
MEASURED: 215 open function-instances / 8,763 instructions are byte-identical (h_exact,
including reloc payloads) to an already-matched function. ONE class is 86% of that pool:
func_801758FC — 55 ins, same address in all 138 overlays, matched in ov_SC01_000 only,
OPEN in the other 137 => 7,535 instructions.
h_exact means identical INCLUDING jal/lui/%lo reloc immediates, so the matched body compiles
byte-identically at every member with NO remap (dedup_extend's correctness argument, §14).
dedup_propagate --addr authored it once as DEFINE_func_801758FC() in engine_core.h and
instantiated it at all 137 open sites in address order.
[ OK ] 138 overlays byte-identical after propagation; 1 new group in config/dedup.us.yaml
VERIFIED: make clean && make extract-all && make check-all -> 140 passed, 0 failed of 140.
Fleet instr 12411467 -> 12419002 = +7,535 EXACTLY; fn-count +137; instr-weighted crosses to
94.5%. distinct-code unchanged BY DESIGN -- the class was already matched in ov_SC01_000, so
the 137 add fleet instructions but no new DISTINCT function. audit-digest OK. 0 NON_MATCHING.
Note this function had been sitting in the stored-draft backlog for ov_SC06_030 and
ov_SC07_010 and re-gated "no" earlier tonight -- because gating a DRAFT is the wrong move for
an h_exact class. The right move is propagating the already-MATCHED body. Same function, two
routes, and only one of them is free.
Remaining free pool after this: 78 instances / 1,228 ins across 32 classes.
The 39 draft-exemplar families all have their exemplar still OPEN in ov_SC01_077 -- a
draft-exemplar family cannot propagate until its head banks. Re-gated the newest stored
ov077 draft per head, in 4 small batches (§61: a wide harvest broke a TU in S38).
Set aside the top 4 heads (65% of the pool's weight, all known-hard): func_801412A8 +
func_80178004 ARE S6's two giant walls (198x138 + 165x138 = 50,094 ins riding on 2 cracks),
func_8017C974 is today's byte-proven close=47, func_8017C294 its 246-ins neighbour.
batch 0 1/9 batch 1 3/9 batch 2 4/9 batch 3 0/8 = 8/35 (23%)
BANKED: func_8017EC7C func_8018281C func_801820DC func_80182988 func_80183BAC
func_80183AF0 func_80183CF4 func_80182E7C
(+474 ins x1 now; ~1,441 ins of templatable weight behind them once their families propagate.)
CALIBRATION REFINEMENT (docs/calibration.md, S39): this population re-gates at 23%, vs 8%
for the general stored pool and 4/6 for fresh post-repair drafts. Three different populations,
three different rates -- which is exactly why the rule is "re-gate what a repair plausibly
touched", not "re-gate the ledger". ov_SC01_077 is the split-heaviest overlay, so the S38
alias-deletion repair plausibly touched all of these.
VERIFIED: make clean && make extract-all && make check-all -> 140 passed, 0 failed of 140.
Fleet 12410275 -> 12410749 instr (+474), distinct +474 / +8 uniq, fn-count +8. audit-digest OK.
0 NON_MATCHING (G4).
Propagation behind the crack banked this session. jtbl_family_bank.py over the 4 open
h_seq siblings of func_801878E8 (513 ins each):
ov_SC03_001 BANKED ov_SC03_124 BANKED
ov_SC04_019 BANKED ov_SC05_017 BANKED
ROUTE NOTE (§53, worth keeping): family_sweep --hseq REFUSED this family by design --
has_mid_jr => it needs the jtbl carve, not the remap sweep, and the interlock says plainly
that "a 0% from this path would be a TOOL artifact, not a wall". Taking the refusal at face
value and using the named tool banked 4/4 first try. This is the same lesson as the rest of
the session from the other side: the instrument told the truth about its own limits.
jtbl_family_bank also enforces a CLEAN tree (it reverts from HEAD per sibling, so an
uncommitted prior bank would be destroyed) -- which is why the ×1 banks committed first (H4).
VERIFIED: make clean && make extract-all && make check-all -> 140 passed, 0 failed of 140
(each sibling carves its own jtbl => config changed => fleet blast radius). Fleet
instr-weighted 12408077 -> 12410129 = +2,052, exactly 4 x 513; distinct +1,539 / +3 unique
fns (the 4th sibling shares an h_exact class already matched); fn-count +4. audit-digest OK.
0 NON_MATCHING (G4).
Session running total: +4,727 instructions (whale 770 + 4 drafts 1,905 + family 2,052),
12405402 -> 12410129, every step R22 clean-fleet 140/140.
The 6 still-open wave-6 drafts were triaged against S38's own diagnosis table; 4 banked,
R22 clean-fleet 140/140.
func_801919A0 ov_SC06_032 710 ins (was: undefined ref func_8018B878 -- "alias class")
func_80189030 ov_SC03_001 557 ins (was: undefined ref func_80186F88 -- "alias class")
func_801878E8 ov_SC04_018 513 ins (was: undefined ref func_801848DC -- "alias class")
func_8018A564 ov_SC02_027 125 ins (was: CC1-FAIL Error 33)
THE FINDING: all four banked with NO change to the drafts. S38 recorded them blocked on a
class that needed cracking ("cracking this one class frees 6 drafts at once"); they had
ALREADY been freed by S38's own tool repairs -- the jr_isolate_all/overlay_src_split
alias-DEFINITION-deletion blindness and harvest_verify._reload_corpus. The drafts were
correct all along; the instruments were failing them. That is the FIFTH recorded "wall"
this phase to resolve to our own tooling.
=> RE-GATE STORED DRAFTS AFTER ANY TOOL REPAIR before treating a stored verdict as a
fact about the code. A verdict is only as current as the instrument that produced it
(R35 applied to the backlog, not just to metrics).
Each bank also performed a jtbl carve, so config/ changed => fleet blast radius => full R22
(clean + extract-all + check-all) = 140 passed, 0 failed of 140.
Metrics move exactly as the model predicts: instr 12406172 -> 12408077 = +1,905, the exact
sum of the four (710+557+513+125); distinct +1,905 / +4 unique fns; fn-count +4.
audit-digest OK. 0 NON_MATCHING (G4).
LEFT ON THE BACKLOG as genuine codegen residuals, not forced (P9):
func_8017C974 (ov_SC01_077, 947 ins, close=47, REGALLOC-PERM, 12 permuter variants inert)
func_80188C68 (ov_SC03_124, 551 ins, close=370, the only target with no twin anywhere)
NEXT: the func_801878E8 family (4 open siblings x 513 ~= +2,052). family_sweep --hseq
correctly REFUSED it via the §53 interlock (has_mid_jr => jtbl carve route; "a 0% from this
path would be a TOOL artifact, not a wall"), and jtbl_family_bank.py requires a clean tree
because it reverts from HEAD per sibling -- which is why this commit lands first.
Closes the first of S38's two reverted R22 failures. ov_SC07_010 was the lone overlay
still shipping func_80144B9C (770 ins) as INCLUDE_ASM while the other 137 banked it.
Its _jr_80140608 object ran 0x184b0..0x2c2f4 straight through the whale; the sibling
ov_SC07_006 carves the same span into _o0d (0x1ca44) + _jr_801457A4 (0x1d64c). Note
0x1ca44 + 0x80128158 = 0x80144B9C exactly.
tools/o0_subsplit.py ov_SC07_010 --lo 0x80144B9C --hi 0x801457A4
-> 1 unmatched stub, 0 ALREADY-MATCHED in range (so no §126 island; K=0 => 3 regions)
-> split BYTE-NEUTRAL first (d7b5875d), then banked via ../shared/func_80144B9C.h
The S38 cause ("its -O0 split reused an EXISTING _o0c instead of a fresh _o0d") did NOT
recur: o0_subsplit.free_letters derives the unused suffix (_o0c is free in THIS overlay).
Two decl conflicts on the way, enumerated with `cdecl` in ONE pass (R33) rather than one
build at a time — of the whale header's 94 symbols the §8b carried layer re-declares 3,
and 2 conflict: D_801274D0 (layer `s32 (*)(s32)`) and D_801274CC (layer `void *`) vs the
header's canonical `s32`. Dropped both: nothing in the region uses them, they are carried
from an earlier region of the old object, and 0 of the 137 other whale-including files
carry either. Decls emit no code => byte-neutral (§8c), and byte-gated.
ov_SC06_030/func_8017E120 needed NO work — it is already banked (defined at
ov_SC06_030_jr_8017C8D0.c:3491). S38 reverted the surrounding batch, not that function.
VERIFIED: make clean && make extract-all && make check-all -> 140 passed, 0 failed of 140
(config changed => fleet blast radius, R22 mandatory). Fleet instr-weighted
12405402 -> 12406172 = +770, exactly the whale's size. distinct-code unchanged by design:
that h_exact class was already matched via the other 137, so the 138th adds fleet
instructions but no new DISTINCT function. audit-digest OK (the new S1e gate, on its first
real use). 0 NON_MATCHING (G4).
Metric note (R30, same class as S1e): a body banked by #include-ing a shared header is
invisible to fn-count's NUMERATOR (the definition is not in the .c) while its stub leaves
the denominator -- 341186/353718 -> 341186/353717. The weighted metrics counted it
correctly because they derive from corpus.stubs, not re-parsed C. Trust the weighted pair.
Still open from S3: the 61 SC07 -O0 members (untouched).
func_80144B9C (770 ins) was matched in 134/138 overlays and open in the four SC07s — 3,080
instructions of code BYTE-IDENTICAL (h_exact, reloc payloads included) to what was already banked,
blocked by a missing file boundary. Now banked in ov_SC07_006 / _007 / _011 for ~0 agent tokens.
R22 clean-fleet 140/140.
THE PLAN'S FRAMING WAS WRONG. This was recorded as "the SC07 carve defect (T2 Arm-A %lo +0x20)".
The carve was never broken: o0_subsplit reported `split byte-neutral` on the FIRST attempt in all
four. The real blocker is that carving the whale out of a jr file makes jr_isolate_all hoist the
parent's file-scope decls into the new region as its `ambient` set — so for the first time the
fleet's loose-typed spellings share a TU with the shared header's (`extern void *D_801274CC` vs
`extern s32 D_801274CC`). In the 134 working overlays the whale sits in a CLEAN -O0 file (common.h +
the header, nothing else) and the two never meet. Fix: drop, in that one file only, the ambient
decls the header already declares — the header being the byte-proven side.
Three iterations, each exposing the next layer of the ambient set, every one a DECLARATION:
1. data symbols (D_80126B58, D_801274CC, D_801274D0)
2. function symbols (func_801336E8, func_8005C324)
3. the alias form terminated by a trailing COMMENT, which an endswith(';') test skipped —
the §134 comment-blindness shape for the THIRD time today.
ov_SC07_010 REVERTED and left open (hence 137/138). Its split landed in an EXISTING _o0c file
rather than a fresh _o0d, producing region _jr_801457A4 whose asm dir splat never generated. It
passed its per-binary build and FAILED the clean-tree R22 — the first R22 failure of the session,
and precisely why a per-binary pass is not a fleet byte claim (§61). Committing on that per-binary
"BANKED" would have shipped a broken overlay.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr families
BY DESIGN — a 0% from the carve-less tool is an artifact, not a wall). Each sibling
individually byte-gated: carve -> extract -> remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff
byte-identical else reverted. Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank requires a
clean tree between families. R22 clean-fleet runs once over the batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr families
BY DESIGN — a 0% from the carve-less tool is an artifact, not a wall). Each sibling
individually byte-gated: carve -> extract -> remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff
byte-identical else reverted. Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank requires a
clean tree between families. R22 clean-fleet runs once over the batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr families
BY DESIGN — a 0% from the carve-less tool is an artifact, not a wall). Each sibling
individually byte-gated: carve -> extract -> remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff
byte-identical else reverted. Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank requires a
clean tree between families. R22 clean-fleet runs once over the batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr families
BY DESIGN — a 0% from the carve-less tool is an artifact, not a wall). Each sibling
individually byte-gated: carve -> extract -> remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff
byte-identical else reverted. Committed per family because jtbl_family_bank requires a
clean tree between families. R22 clean-fleet runs once over the batch.
ROOT CAUSE (byte-witnessed, P30 S38 — the fifth tool with this same blindness).
A function banked under the §37/§73 DEFINITION-SIDE ASM-LABEL ALIAS form is spelled with a private
C identifier and bound to its real symbol by a GNU asm label:
void aF8018A860(s32, s16 *, u8 *, u8 *) __asm__("func_80183AF8"); <- decl, stays in preamble
void aF8018A860(s32, s16 *, u8 *, u8 *) { ... } <- THIS emits func_80183AF8
overlay_src_split.addr_of() resolves `func_<hex>` arithmetically and everything else through `syms`.
`aF8018A860` matches NEITHER, so it returned None — and partition() keeps only items with a
resolved address, so the definition was dropped from EVERY region. The file was then rewritten
without it and nothing said so. One carve of ov_SC02_028 deleted the definitions emitting BOTH
func_80183AF8 and func_80184268; the overlay stopped linking with `undefined reference`, and six
wave-6 drafts were written off against that as a plumbing/compiler wall.
TWO FIXES:
- CAUSE: overlay_src_split now builds an asm-label alias map from the source and resolves a
definition through its EMITTED SYMBOL rather than its C name (verified: aF8018A860 -> 0x80183AF8,
aF8018AFD0 -> 0x80184268 — exactly the two symbols the link was missing).
- SILENCE: partition() and jr_isolate_all._partition() now REFUSE to rewrite a file when any
construct's address does not resolve (R32), instead of discarding it. That guard alone would
have surfaced this the first time it happened.
RESULT: 3 of the 6 alias-class wave-6 drafts bank immediately, for ZERO agent tokens —
func_801884D8 (137 ins) · func_80180B04 (251) · func_801380E0 (438). R22 clean-fleet 140/140.
The other 3 (the three LARGEST: 557/513/710 ins) have a second, size-correlated cause — open.
NOTE FOR THE FLYWHEEL: family_remap._alias_decl_for ALREADY handled this exact form, and its
docstring records the identical lesson ("that blindness was the WHOLE of the h_seq sweep's 137 'no
matched unit' skips. The tool, not the compiler (R35)"). The fix was never propagated. The alias
form needs ONE shared oracle, the way §134 comment-masking ended up on cdecl._mask — five tools
have now independently rediscovered it.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr
families by design). Each sibling individually byte-gated: carve -> extract ->
remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff byte-identical else reverted. Committed here
because jtbl_family_bank requires a clean tree between families (its per-sibling
revert restores from HEAD). R22 clean-fleet runs once over the whole batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr
families by design). Each sibling individually byte-gated: carve -> extract ->
remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff byte-identical else reverted. Committed here
because jtbl_family_bank requires a clean tree between families (its per-sibling
revert restores from HEAD). R22 clean-fleet runs once over the whole batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr
families by design). Each sibling individually byte-gated: carve -> extract ->
remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff byte-identical else reverted. Committed here
because jtbl_family_bank requires a clean tree between families (its per-sibling
revert restores from HEAD). R22 clean-fleet runs once over the whole batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path; family_sweep --hseq refuses has_mid_jr
families by design). Each sibling individually byte-gated: carve -> extract ->
remap -> whole-binary build, kept iff byte-identical else reverted. Committed here
because jtbl_family_bank requires a clean tree between families (its per-sibling
revert restores from HEAD). R22 clean-fleet runs once over the whole batch.
jtbl_family_bank (the §53 carve path — family_sweep --hseq correctly REFUSED these as has_mid_jr
families, warning that a 0% from the non-carve path would be a TOOL artifact, not a wall).
func_8017FEE0 (299 ins, cross-address family of 19 open siblings): 15 BANKED, 4 gate-fail.
Each sibling individually byte-gated by jtbl_family_bank (carve -> extract -> remap -> build, keep
iff byte-identical else revert). R22 clean-fleet runs once over the whole propagation batch; this
commit exists because jtbl_family_bank REQUIRES a clean tree between families (its per-sibling
revert restores from HEAD, so an uncommitted prior family would be destroyed).
Drew T